Nothing ivy-covered about these students

This morning, I had the chance to speak to a group of students in Susan Dobscha’s class at Bentley College. All I can say is: marketers, you’d better get ready for some big changes.

These students don’t have to be taught concepts like conversation marketing, customer engagement and the value of social media. They live it every day. They throw around words like “transparency” as easily as their predecessors used “CPM.” They understand intuitively that marketing is about relationships and what they termed “deep branding.” That means embedding a brand on a customer’s mind through a long-term series of interactions that stress value for both parties.

The topic turned to Facebook for a while, and it’s clear that the students regard it as a tool to facilitate relationships. They maintain very large networks of casual acquaintances — one student described them as the people you say “hi” to in the hallway but don’t stop to talk to — and social networks are a means to accomplish this. I asked a class of about 25 students if any of them had formed meaningful relationships online and only one hand went up. Despite what the older generation may think, these kids value personal relationships as much as anybody else, it’s just that they expect to maintain friends networks that are five or six times as large as those of their parents. Imagine how business will be done differently when millions of these people hit the workforce.

One innovative project that this class is pursuing is maintaining a blog. Each student is required to follow a single blogger and to comment upon his or her writings during the course of the semester. These real-time observations are incorporated into the curriculum, making the classroom conversation about as current as any I have ever seen. The instructor told me that this is Bentley’s first social media marketing course and that enrollment filled up in 20 minutes. You can see why: these kids understand where the future lies and they’re not weighted down by assumptions about how marketing should be done. Beginning next year, some of them will be working for you. I would advise you to listen carefully to what they have to say. And Bentley should take those enrollment numbers as a message.

I had lunch with a small group of Bentley marketing faculty, several of whom specialize in marketing analytics. One professor asked me, somewhat ruefully, if marketers have wasted the last 20 years perfecting their analytical skills. I’m afraid I only gave half an answer. I said that the focus on analytics was a function of the limitations of media at the time. In other words, it was impossible to have meaningful conversations with customers until a few years ago, so marketers focused on measuring the limited contact they had.

What I should have said was that analytics will be even more important in the coming era. The Internet is the most measurable medium ever invented, and the challenge for marketers will be to develop useful metrics from a vast menu of options. The marketing analytics discipline should only grow in importance as people sort through all the choices. While it’s true that relationship marketing demands different skills that analytical marketing, that doesn’t make analytical skills any less important. Quite the contrary.

Daily reading 02/18/2008

ReGeneration – Dell’s green blog

tags: social_media_useful

  • In case you missed this one (I certainly did), Dell’s got a blog devoted to its conservation efforts. Public policy issues are great topics for corporations to blog about. The topics inspire passion and cast the company in a positive light. There’s a very neat graffiti idea at the top of this blog.
     – post by pgillin

Shel Israel Interviews Michael Dell about social media – Society for New Communications Research, Feb. 12, 2008

tags: social_media_useful

  • You’ve got to hand it to Dell. It’s been the victim of a couple of notable blog swarms, but rather than getting defensive and resentful it has embraced criticism as a challenge to do better. I was surprised to learn that Dell made 35 changes/improvements to its products last year as a result of IdeaStorm.
     – post by pgillin

Universal Wrecking Corporation Announces New Corporate Blog – Newswire, Feb. 17, 2008

tags: social_media_useful

Gag me with a Constitution

This post originally appeared on my Newspaper Death Watch blog, but I wanted to share:

I got a call today from a journalist who’s doing a story on the future of newspapers and he shared an interesting tidbit. He said he had contacted a prominent thought leader in the journalism field, whom I won’t name. This thought leader had said that the impending collapse of the newspaper industry was “a threat to democracy.”

Excuse me, but what? A threat to democracy? Newspapers are dying, in large part, because of democracy. The rise of citizen publishing has made it possible, for the first time, for large numbers of ordinary citizens to publish to a global audience without the intercession of media institutions. What could be more democratic than that? If Thomas Jefferson was alive today, he’d be an active blogger. Social media is the most democratic process to hit the publishing industry in 500 years.

I’m going to give the thought leader the benefit of the doubt and assume that he was referring to the decline of investigative journalism as practiced by newspapers. On that point, I’ll defer to journalism professor Steve Boriss, who argues that a lot of what passes for investigative journalism today is simply reporters acting as conduits for whistle-blowers. Those malcontents will find other outlets for their gripes, whether it be Consumerist.com or something else. I’m quite confident that the market will take care of filling the need for advocacy reporting.

I think the threat-to-democracy statement is more a function of the arrogance of traditional news journalists, who believe that a system in which a few thousand editors decide what people should know is superior to one in which many millions of citizens make those same judgments. If citizen media is a threat to democracy, I shudder to think of the alternative.

Reinventing U.S. Innovation

From Innovations, a website published by Ziff-Davis Enterprise from mid-2006 to mid-2009. Reprinted by permission.

John KaoJohn Kao (right) believes the United States has an innovation crisis, and he’s calling on today’s corps of young technology professionals to sound the alarm.

Citing technology pioneer Vannevar Bush’s assertion more than 60 years ago that “A nation that loses its science and technology will lose control of its destiny,” Kao said the U.S. is in peril of becoming a technology laggard.

“The US public education system is veering further away from preparing kids for the world,” the author of Innovation Nation: How America Is Losing Its Innovation Edge, Why It Matters, and What We Can Do to Get It Back told the MIT Enterprise Forum early this month. “We spend more on education than any country in world, yet we’re between 24th and 29th in math performance.”

By contrast, Finland, a country that suffered a near economic collapse after the Soviet Union fell apart, today produces twice as many Ph.D.s per capita than the U.S. The Finns turned around their economy, in part, by creating a national design focused on science and technology education. As a result, “Two years ago, Finland was the number one competitive economy in the world, according to the World Economic Forum,” Kao said. “Its education system is rated the best in the world. People want to be teachers in Finland.”

We’ve heard this before, of course.  In the late 1980s, Japan famously challenged the US for leadership in technology innovation with initiatives like the Fifth Generation Computer Project and a nationwide commitment to developing artificial intelligence.  Those ambitious plans foundered, but Kao argues that this time is different.

Today, countries like Singapore and China are making technology innovation the centerpiece of a national strategy that’s backed by incentives, equipment and money. Singapore, for example, has set up the Biopolis, a $300 million biomedical research lab spread across a 10-acre campus. Singapore is allocating money to train expatriate scientists in other countries on the condition that they repay the government with six years of service. The country is also promising to remove the layers of bureaucracy and legal approvals that frustrate scientists in the U.S.

Singapore has convinced top researchers from MIT and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control to pull up stakes and move to the tiny nation-state with financial incentives and promises of academic freedom.

This last point is a key difference between the national technology policies of today and the failed models of two decades ago.  Thanks to the Internet and business globalization, countries now have the capacity to build very large local industries serving overseas customers. Kao told of a friend who’s building a global travel business for 1/10th of what it would have cost a decade ago. He farms out much of the development work overseas. “Countries want to ally with American intellectual capital,” he said.

Therein lies a challenge for US competitiveness. The United States has long been able to rely upon the global brain drain from other countries to fuel its innovation economy. Over half of the engineering Ph.D.s awarded in the U.S. now go to foreign-born students. Many of those people have traditionally settled in Silicon Valley or other technology-rich environments. But the lifestyle trade-offs aren’t as dramatic as they used to be. “Now there’s an Apple store and a Starbucks in Bangalore [India],“ Kao said.

With overseas economies offering tax havens, comfortable salaries, research grants and other perks to technology achievers, some countries that used to lose talent to the US have actually reversed the migration.

What can US technology professionals do?  Well, on a purely selfish level there may be some attractive opportunities to pull up stakes and move overseas. Singapore, for example, has earmarked a half billion dollars to fund digital imagine research. But if you’re more interested in improving the domestic situation, then start by voting for candidates that have a vision and a plan for US technology competitiveness.

You can also out into the classroom and share your own experiences with tomorrow’s innovators.  Many teachers would be glad for the help. In John Kao’s words, “Many people who teach math and science in U.S. public schools are forced to do it.” In contrast, “In China, people with masters degrees in math willingly come in to teach in the schools.”

A personal finance how-to book with a bilingual twist

Years ago, when I was an editor at Computerworld, I got to know Lynn Jimenez at KGO radio in San Francisco. She would often call me when there was breaking tech news and she needed some quick perspective. Over dozens of interviews, she proved to be a more valuable media trainer than any high-priced consultant I’ve ever worked with.

Lynn works at warp speed. She’s the morning business reporter on the top AM station in the Bay Area and she usually broadcasts from the frantic floor of the Pacific Stock Exchange. You can be having a perfectly normal conversation with Lynn and she will suddenly excuse herself, turn away and deliver a perfectly timed one-minute market update to 100,000 drive-time listeners as casually as if she were answering the phone. Then she’ll turn back and pick up the conversation in mid-stream. I don’t know how she does it.

Somehow, she’s found time to write a book about personal finance, and it’s got an interesting twist. ¿Se Habla Dinero? is written in Spanish and English. The Spanish pages are on the left and the English pages are on the right. So the book is both a guide to personal finance and a translation guide. This is important to Spanish-speaking immigrants, who are easily intimidated by the jargon and pressure involved in high-stakes financial decisions. They can take this book with them and easily find the English words they need.

As a practical guide, ¿Se Habla Dinero? is a plain-talk tutorial that’s accessible and understandable. Lynn Jimenez isn’t a specialist in personal finance, but she knows plenty of people who are. She’s taken a journalist’s approach by interviewing the experts in all areas and boiling down their advice into plain English – and Spanish. The book is comprehensive and easy to read, and the bilingual format is a bonus for readers who are still climbing the language curve.

Daily reading 02/07/2008

Marriott – Marriott in the Kitchen – Brad Nelson’s Blog

tags: corporate_blog_examples, social_media_useful

  • Building on the apparent success of the blog by Bill Marriott, Chairman & CEO of the big hotel chain, Marriott has launched a culinary blog written by its corporate chef. This is a low-impact, non-controversial way to extend the blogging metaphor to an area in which Marriott evidently wants to highlight its capabilities. The company has not historically been known for its food, and this is an effort to build awareness around that competency. It’s nicely done.
     – post by pgillin